Odalin: Dungeons of Doom Review

• Overview
• Gameplay
• What I Like
• What I Don’t Like
• Components
• Voice / Art / Music
• The Tales Told
• You Might Like This Game If…
• Score

Overview

From publisher Dragori Games:

Experience the thrill of classic dungeon crawlers, infused with great strategic depth, in a unique dark desert fantasy setting. Find immersion and nostalgia in the intense battles that only the bravest souls dare to explore. With straightforward rules and innovative mechanics, every encounter is unique—you will never know what lurks within the shadowy pits of the dungeons.

Make a pact with a demon lord and combine your attacks with the demon’s, creating a unique combinations and gameplay for each hero. There are dice rolling, but the powers allow to mitigate the luck with good strategy.

Explore the dungeons to find artifacts and hidden secrets, with an exciting loot system. Many items are unusual and make real impact on the hero’s powers. With luck, you can find the set collection for your hero and become much more powerful.

Make tough choices, including moral dilemma and shape the campaign. Your choices will shape the world and determine the ending.

Odalin: Dungeons of Doom is a dungeon crawl board game with a larger narrative wrapper than most, crowdfunded on Gamefound in one print run. It had an ambitious timeline for its promise of a large amount of content. I’ll only be covering the core game in this review, but I’ll mention some of the available add-ons.

Player count

Supporting 1 – 4 players, soloists still need to use at least two heroes, or use a full four with a set of supplemental rules to simplify some of the other hero’s turns. I haven’t tried the simplified version, instead playing two handed solo, where I think the sweet spot is. The game’s many things to remember, including out-of-turn actions, will probably overwhelm casual players at higher hero counts, so running a full group of four is best left for an experienced game group.

Play time

Odalin’s campaign is massive, running 100+ hours to complete all five chapters. Following trends of other modern games, a chapter is split into: 1. A narrative introduction, complete with branching story choices and a check sheet to mark those decisions. 2. The dungeon itself, split into rooms connected by door tokens. After a series of rooms, players arrive at Sanctuary checkpoints. These rest areas reset the heroes, power them up, and also remove previous tiles, so there’s no worry about having the entire dungeon on the table at once. While each room’s fight may take 20-30 minutes, the string of rooms between each sanctuary might take 2-3 hours.

Setup is relatively complex, with quite a few tokens, cards, and miniatures to pull out for each dungeon room. I’ve played games with worse setup times, but I’ve also played ones with better. Odalin reminds me a little bit of Chronicles of Drunagor, with long setup for battles that are relatively simple.

Gameplay

Odalin is a dungeon crawler, through and through. There is no overworld map, just the narrative to string the chapters together. Almost all time is spent in the massive dungeons going room to room and fighting enemies.

Heroes and Demons

Assuming the role of one of eight heroes, players take unique abilities, starting weapons and statistics, and a deck of twelve ability cards to start their adventure. Right out of the gate, players are presented with another choice, which demon to meld their hero with.

There are five demons players can choose from, each with different abilities that specialize in a different role. Once chosen, players take demon cards and attach them to their hero cards, placing them in specially provided sleeves. This produces a set of unique top and bottom abilities, very much like Gloomhaven.

Additionally, players will occasionally transform into these demons, whether by choice, or if the demon takes over. If by choice, the players can use unique demon abilities in battle for a limited time, but if the demon takes over, the hero becomes an additional enemy that the group needs to tackle.

Finally, players have statistics. These are marked by indentations around their characters boards where numbered tokens slot in, providing bonuses for everything from pure damage, defense, or hp, to the ability to flip some of their cards to their enhanced, more powerful side.

Dungeons and Narrative

Similar to other dungeon crawlers, Odalin plays on dungeon tiles. Each room has one to many doors to other areas, with most of them initiating combat. It’s a bit of a throwback to Warhammer Quest, just without the randomization. There are about 5 or so rooms before players rest at a Sanctuary, where they reset, and level up. Room contents are dictated by the campaign book, describing enemy setup, interactable objects, and any special rules that room has. Each chapter has five sanctuaries, then a boss encounter.

Of note, there is a randomization mode, but it’s light and what I would consider underdeveloped. Called Hell Rifts, some sanctuaries provide the opportunity to enter another plane of existence and battle a random set of enemies in a randomly drawn room up to several times. Each cleared room provides a small amount of equipment, so it’s another way to chew through the large equipment decks to search for the juiciest of it.

On the narrative side, while each room has an introductory paragraph and then the interactable objects to discover later, it’s all fairly light and straightforward. To open each chapter, players read and progress through a much larger narrative story, complete with choices, skill tests, and rewards or punishments sprinkled throughout. It’s reminiscent of Oathsworn or Dante, and the writing in Odalin is definitely good enough to keep players engaged.

Villains

While there aren’t a lot of enemies in Odalin, some even being reused for upgraded versions in later chapters, they are unique. Each has its own deck of cards dictating everything from AI behavior, to unique abilities and attacks. These are done well enough that there’s clear distinction, with snake men poisoning, bandit archers delivering sniper shots, and sorcerers buffing, pushing, or pulling heroes around the map. Furthermore, enemies are distinguished by different colored and shaped bases. This prevents an enemy from being #1, #5, #12 etc. which is a common issue with some dungeon crawlers. It’s a neat idea that’s a nice quality of life feature.

Combat

There’s quite a bit that goes into Odalin’s combat. Players draw four cards from their deck of twelve, then use them, or standard actions available to everyone, to perform three actions per turn. One big caveat: players can only play one attack card per turn. This limits the amount of burst a player can output regardless of how their deck is constructed, forcing them to round out their decks with utility. Examples of such are auras that buff the hero and stay on the board, temporary buffs, healing, or instant cards. Instants are interesting, they are out of turn actions that players can perform at any time other than their own turn. While these are largely buffs or curses, they can also be decent amounts of damage, so saving a card for its instant action can be preferable.

When attacking, there’s a few things to consider. First is the dice pool, where players roll all colored attack die from all the items they have equipped. Attacks need to breach defense, so the die results plus card modifiers need “hits” equal to, or greater than the enemy’s defense. If these hits exceed the defense values by three or more, then the attack is a critical hit, allowing players to add critical hit damage from their luck stat. The rest of the damage comes from results on the die, the attack power of the card, extra damage from the strength stat, and any special modifiers like flanking. All of it is added together for a final total, then subtracted from the enemy’s hp. If all this sounds like a lot, it is, but it flows surprisingly well after a bit of practice.

Itemization and Progression

After each combat, equipment and consumables are dished out in measured amounts, usually two to three of each. Players can then swap their gear and update their resulting statistic changes before continuing on. At each sanctuary, players level up and take one new card from the bank of cards at their level, or any prior cards from previous levels that they didn’t choose before. They can then swap out the new card for one of their existing and continue on.

Of note is that there are legendary, and set items in the equipment decks. Borrowing from Diablo, these provide much greater utility than regular items, are rare, and can make a big impact on playstyles. Examples might be adding a dash ability, a healing ability, a buff, and more.

What I Like

Odalin has many great concepts to its design. It hooks off of other games in the genre like Gloomhaven, Oathsworn, and Warhammer Quest, yet still stands on its own. It does a genius job at streamlining, adding, and concentrating dungeon crawl concepts into something unique.

Customization and Progression

Starting with a big bright highlight, Odalin’s systems unfold in a really satisfying way. Beginning with the choice of demon to merge with, players get to take an already specialized hero and pull it in further directions. This could create a pure glass cannon damage dealer, healer or defender, or a mix of both. This option isn’t locked in stone either. Players can freely switch to any unused demon at each sanctuary by simply changing the demon cards attached to their hero cards. I found myself routinely swapping demons as the game progressed so I could maximize utility with how my heroes were evolving.

From there, new equipment and consumables sprinkled like congratulatory confetti keeps the loot flowing and the options wide. While most gear is simple and won’t break the mental bank, some unique and set pieces are pretty transformational. I found some items had a pretty big impact on playstyle, especially ones that boosted the statistics allowing for upgraded cards. There doesn’t seem to be a wrong way to play, either, which is great, just more options to push in whatever direction players want to take their heroes in.

Transformative progression takes a while to achieve, but over the course of a chapter, my heroes walked away feeling much more powerful than they did going on. This progression is just about right for the campaign’s length, and it’s one aspect that Odalin nails.

Combat

After getting over the learning curve, Odalin’s combat started to click pretty quickly. It’s clear the designer was going for a strong tactical experience, requiring a lot of thinking to go into everything from which attack to use, to how to position your hero.

I really enjoyed getting into the turn by turn grit of combat, jumping around the field, dropping area of effect attacks, and managing HP and corruption so as to not tip over into certain doom. There’s quite a bit to manage in the single attack, out of turn instants, character abilities, and HP/corruption management.

The overall balance felt about right, though there are certainly some items, abilities, and enemies that are far better than others. To add to this, the game offers several difficulty modes. Going easier means less corruption during play, and going harder adds elite buffs to regular enemies, usually doubling their hp. There are tools for players to better balance the game how they’d like, and I like that addition.

Narrative

While it’s long, I enjoyed Odalin’s narrative. Taking place in a Diablo’esque fantasy Egyptian themed world, it stands apart from the standard European swords and sorcery style. The writing is well done, sets the stage well for the dungeon encounters, and there’s some interesting immersive qualities to it.

Furthermore, I like that the dungeon rooms are defined by the objects within. Tokens are used, and reused for points of interest, and good narrative descriptions go a long way to making everything feel more unique even with repeated visuals. One pleasant surprise was the inclusion of puzzles. Some objects will be collectible for later, and some will have players solve something, with the solution provided in the back of the campaign book. It reminds me of a D&D adventure, and I actually wish there were more of these that took more of the spotlight over the heavy emphasis on combat.

Initiative and Enemy Identification

There’s some cool quality of life things in Odalin. Initiative is simple, shuffling one card per enemy model into a deck with hero cards to create the initiative track for each combat. While there’s a tiny bit of manipulation that can happen here, it’s mostly set, so players can plan around it quite well. In addition, enemy stats are all printed on the initiative cards themselves, so there’s no need for separate ones hanging around the table.

What I Don’t Like

It’s unfortunate that with so much to like, there’s a lot of Odalin that feels underbaked. I think much of it needed another pass to tighten it all up,. Quite a few of the mechanics that I hadn’t mentioned as my favorites are because they feel tacked on rather than essential.

Rules

Starting with the rules, they are probably the most egregious part of the game. Out of the box, it is almost unplayable. Many rules are left out, unclear, or just plain wrong. One example is how the attack dice are gathered: The description would have you believe you use only the dice on weapons for attacking, and only the dice on armor for defending, but this is not the case. Weapons can have defensive die and armor offensive die. This has been cleared up in an errata, so while it’s not an absolute deal breaker, it sucks to struggle so much. What can’t be so easily fixed, however, are more errors, spelling mistakes, incorrect, or wrong words used on the cards and other printed material. While I did not find anything game breaking, it was further disappointing to see just how many there are.

In addition, the rules clearly and plainly call out a Quickstart guide that does not exist. No one received it because Dragori said that they never made one. Apparently at the last minute, play testers deemed it not necessary so it was skipped. Shockingly, and with how bad the rules are, I think I would have greatly appreciated having one to help get the initial setup straight, because that was also unclear. It’s supremely disappointing that a game that is supposed to pride itself on quality would release in such a bad state.

Progression and Balance

Odalin’s card abilities are all over the place. Some attacks are extremely weak, dealing just two or four damage while others deal 10+. Some utility is super situational like only when an enemy dies, and others just not very useful, like healing only two damage when opportunities to heal much more exist. In fact, during my play, I found it far more efficient to not transform into a demon, because each spirit saved beyond the maximum amount heals one hit point.

In terms of progression, while I do like its consistent drip, I don’t feel it’s ever earned. It feels guaranteed, and I never felt like I had to work for something special. There’s no pushing luck or kicking down just another door for a shot at loot. Battles are static and predetermined for in each room, as are the rewards for it. Don’t get me wrong, there are definitely hidden items as well as regular equipment, there’s just not many wow moments. Touching everything and going everywhere, you’ll get most of it.

Weak Mechanics

One that comes to mind is where a hero loses control of the demon inside them and becomes an enemy. On paper, it’s cool, but in practice, it means that a hero is probably never going to lose control. Rather than succumb, they can just run away and heal their corruption by trading it for HP. I don’t want to say this event never happens, but it’s really rare. If it were reworked, I think it would really shine.

I touched on the Hell Rifts already, but additional battles for only sprinkles of loot is not appealing. It feels uninspired and tacked on rather than meaningful because it’s just more of the same. What I’d like to have seen are some unique challenges for guaranteed rewards like legendary or unique items. These type of challenges do exist in optional rooms, but I think would serve better as the Hell Rifts themselves. As it is, I usually skipped them.

I’ll mention the skill tests as well. Sprinkled throughout the game are tests that work much like D&D: a d20 roll plus a given hero’s stat. But again, the mechanic feels tacked on, and inconsequential. Tests pop up at random, and the rewards are almost always very basic. It doesn’t make characters feel like they’ve achieved something special, just that something arbitrary happened or didn’t happen.

Repetition

Odalin’s campaign is long, but the variety within it is light. There’s less than ten enemy types in the whole game, and generally you are fighting just one or two types for an entire chapter. While there’s some variety to the rooms with a few special rules sprinkled in, it’s not enough to switch up the monotony. After even just a few rooms doing what feels like the same fights over and over, I felt ready to move on.

I would have much preferred a campaign that was half the length, but twice as interesting. There should be more puzzles and non combat, more interesting characters to encounter, more side areas to challenge me, and more reasons to come back again. I won’t remember there was a sick snake person looking for their friend, but I do remember the unique boss that can raise fallen enemies from the dead, and the resulting powerful item I got from them, or the puzzles that stopped me in my tracks and teased my brain.

Fiddly Gameplay

There are a lot of things to keep track of in Odalin. Between hero statistics, items, conditions, auras, hero specific auras, flanking, and other hero’s instants, it’s easy to forget something. I think quite a lot of it could be streamlined away with a good round of revision. Flanking for example, while an interesting idea, does almost nothing. Rarely used, careful positioning to avoid damage is far better than running in and risking oneself for a meagre extra point of flank damage.

Conditions are another example. Overall quite weak, fiddly, and uninspired, all conditions work in 2’s. Adding two damage, reducing two damage, taking two damage a turn etc. two is generally small enough to be ignored. The one exception is stacking. Many times the game asks the player to ignore the condition maximum, allowing infinite stacks of a condition. Now this certainly does have an effect that can’t be ignored, but then it immediately becomes fiddly when needing to add up huge stacks of tokens each turn, plus it’s entirely possible to simply run out of tokens at a certain point.

Poor English

Normally I can give a pass for some bad English, but Odalin has it in spades. We aren’t just talking about a hiccup here and there, entire words are wrong, context is wrong, dashes break up words oddly, and don’t get me started on grammatical errors. Throwing the text through a very simple tool like Grammarly would have caught all of this. It’s pretty outrageous to see this much laziness in such a big production.

Components

Odalin’s components struggle quite a bit. In the initial print run, the game came riddled with errors, missing tokens, and some cards had incorrect art. To Dragori’s credit, they did reprint the bad content and send it out for free, but it really shouldn’t have happened to that level in the first place.

As far as the miniatures go, I don’t think they are the best, neither are they the worst I’ve seen. Some are better than others, but overall the details on them is soft. You can tell it’s there, but it’s very light and would disappear instantly under even a moderately thick paint job. This could be in part due to the fact that they’re made from the same type of hard plastic. While I appreciate that from a durability standpoint, I’m not sure they’re the best for high quality painting.

One of the other problems I have with the miniatures is their bombastic size. Compared to the tiles they sit on, and with tiny bases, their weapons and arms stick out tremendously. When clustered together, everything looks like a big blob, and models will get caught on each other. Folklore: The Affliction has a similar problem. I did not purchase the miniatures for that game and was quite happy to use standees. Besides this, however, the sculpts are interesting, and the poses dynamic, so they’re definitely cool, just maybe less practical.

Finally, cards and cardboard are of good quality and the transparent demon cards sleeved into the player decks are pretty neat. I did not see any warping, tearing, or fraying, and the game box itself is plenty sturdy.

Expansions

For the add-ons, there’s one big expansion, then a few smaller boxes like extra heroes, demons, and bosses.

• Sands of Destruction – This is the first expansion for Odalin. Containing a new adventure with new foes, it does not add new heroes or demons, but offers another long adventure and new bosses to fight.
• Lust, Wraith, Hunger, Darkness – These are new demons for the players to choose from. I can’t comment on how good they are, but for those enjoying Odalin, more options are always good.
• Heroes of War and Magic – New heroes! Each box has four, for eight in total.
• Abaddon and Dragon – Cosmetic upgrades and extra bosses to fight in Odalin and Tanares.
• Special Tiles Pack – These are cosmetic alternatives to the tiles the game uses. To me these are essential, since the dungeon tiles in the game are so boring and reused so much.
• Acrylic tokens, Dice tray etc. – Cosmetic fluff, I skip this stuff, but it’s nice for all-in players.

Voice / Art / Music

Voice

Odalin has a full Foreteller release! 13.5 hours of dialog – whoa! I highly recommend this for group play; no one wants to read 40 minutes of dialog to introduce a chapter.

Art

Here’s something I want to dive into a little deeper. I’ll start by saying that generally speaking, I like Odalin’s art. The catch is that it uses AI assistance. Now, AI art has been a pretty big sore spot for a lot of people over the last few years. To Dragori’s credit, they’ve come out and fully admitted they use it in the process (unlike other companies, Hasbro…).

Below is one example they give on how they use AI to start, then have artists finish the work.

I’ll say this about AI: the technology isn’t going anywhere. Instead of try some kind of hardline boycott, I think it’s alright to embrace AI as a tool. It’s very good at recreating what it’s been taught, but it’s very poor at being creative. This means that for generic art with generic themes in generic games, it’s probably fine. What this really means is that truly unique art from real artists should be valued much higher, and individual styles need to be cherished for the real art pieces that they are. Again, I do like Odalin’s art, but it is on the generic side.

Music

There’s no official soundtrack for Odalin, but any of your favorite dungeon crawl classic soundscapes work. I think Diablo 2’s second act tracks works particularly well here, as Odalin clearly has Diablo inspiration.

The Tales Told

There are some minor spoilers ahead, but I’ll speak briefly about Odalin’s story overall. Ignoring the English, I’ll touch on the narrative of the five acts overall.

I’ll start by saying that I quite liked Odalin’s writing. It’s straightforward but immersive, and for a board game it does the job well. I was not blown away by the narrative choices, and there are only a few characters that stick around. Still, it’s in line with others in the genre and it’s a fun inclusion. Besides the chapter introductions, room flavor text is simple, usually just describing how angry enemies are lying in wait. It’s the objects in each room that really helped immerse me in the area.

Chapter 1

Players are thrown into the world of Odalin by sneaking past snake men and merging with their chosen demons. It’s soon discovered that others are after you, but you have a problem to deal with first: the demons are slowly corrupting you. Only the Djinn of healing can slow the progression, so it’s onto a journey to find it. Taking place primarily in a dungeon full of more corrupted snake people, it’s unveiled that a pact for power went wrong and the once decidedly less hostile snake men are now driven mad by the infection that is slowly killing them. I found the introduction fitting, just long.

You Might Like This Game If…

At this point, and with the issues Odalin has, I would wait before picking it up. I would recommend Gloomhaven/Frosthaven, the new game Rove, or even Dragori’s own Tanares Adventures before Odalin. This is for the simple reason that the mechanics in those games flow better.

That said, if the negatives I mentioned don’t sound that negative, and the positives – tactical dungeon crawling with a steady stream of loot in a very Diablo way – sound incredible, then Odalin may delight. There is a really unique core to Odalin that I enjoyed, so I’d imagine dungeon crawl enthusiasts can look past the majority of the game’s issues and view the game in high regard anyway.

For gaming groups, if one player took time to learn the rules first and then explain them to the others, plus if Forteller is used to help with the lengthy narratives, I can see the game appealing to some. I’d have no problem letting teens play the game, as there aren’t themes mature enough to ward anyone off, though the mechanics will be simply too heavy for kids to enjoy.

Score

It’s quite a shame that Odalin was rushed out of the oven and into our hands. While I’m as eager for my crowdfunded games as the next backer, it really is better to trade patience for quality. While accidents happen, and I can overlook a production error or two, I’m baffled that the game’s components released in the state they’re in. Equally perplexing are play testers that seemingly glossed over gameplay issues and even suggested skipping the Quickstart Guide entirely.

Already in desperate need of a second edition, Odalin is an unpolished gem. There are real glimpses of greatness that shine through, and I really think the game could one day be cemented in dungeon crawl history. Easily jumping in score when the production, miniature, and rule issues are fixed, it could jump again if core systems like demon transformation, conditions, balance, campaign length, and Hell Rifts all got a round of updates. I’ll be a backer of any future editions and expansions since I really want to see where it goes.

Odalin gets a 2/5 without a golden quill.